© Colonne / Canva

This one is for Mar - Balance, balance, balance...

They say you should never mix business with pleasure, but what about friendship with romance? Picture this: you’re in a tight-knit group of friends, sharing inside jokes, spontaneous adventures, and that perfect balance of camaraderie. Then one day, you lock eyes with one of them and think, Could we be something more? Fast forward, and suddenly, the friend group dynamics are one awkward conversation away from imploding.

Trust me, I’ve been there. And while there are definite perks—no awkward “getting to know you” stage, a shared social circle, and having someone who knows you’re Team Pineapple Pizza—it’s not always the fairytale it seems. In fact, in my experience, dating within the friend group felt less like a rom-com and more like walking a tightrope… without a safety net.

The Group vs. The Couple Dilemma

When my ex and I decided to dive into something more than friendship, I thought, This is going to be amazing! We already love hanging out. But the reality? Our relationship became a footnote in the friend group story. Date night? Forget it. Any plans we made would be swallowed whole by group outings. Romantic one-on-one dinners turned into pizza nights with everyone. And when it was just the two of us, I couldn’t quite make the mental leap from “we’re best buds” to “we’re a couple now.” It was as if our connection was missing a crucial spark—and I couldn’t ignore it.

Worse still, the lines between friendship and romance blurred in ways I wasn’t prepared for. When you’re dating someone in your friend group, their quirks that were once amusing can suddenly become unbearable in a romantic context. And how do you argue or express frustration with someone who’s also your friend, without it becoming group drama? Every disagreement felt like a ripple threatening to turn into a tidal wave.

Love or Loneliness?

I’ll admit, fear played a role in my decision to stay in the relationship as long as I did. Breaking up meant risking not just the relationship, but the entire group dynamic. If we split, what would happen to everyone else? Would the group pick sides? Would it fracture completely? Spoiler alert: the group did implode when we broke up, but honestly? It was like breaking free from a cage I didn’t even realize I was in.

Sometimes, the fear of loneliness tricks us into thinking a mediocre relationship is better than none. I’d convinced myself that staying meant stability for the group, but really, it just meant losing myself. I felt trapped by the unspoken responsibility of keeping the group intact. And in the end, all it did was make me miserable.

But here’s the thing: the world didn’t end. Yes, the group dynamic changed, but it also allowed me to reevaluate what I needed in both friendships and relationships. It’s a painful but necessary lesson—and one that taught me that fear is never a good reason to stay.

Finding the Balance… If You Dare

Now, I’m not saying dating someone in your friend group is doomed to fail. Some couples manage to strike that elusive balance between romance and friendship. But let’s be honest: finding that sweet spot is like trying to eat spaghetti in a white shirt—possible, but very risky.

Here are some tips if you’re thinking of taking the plunge:

1. Set Boundaries Early – Make sure you carve out time for just the two of you. Your relationship deserves space to grow without the group constantly hovering.

2. Talk About the "What Ifs" – What happens if it doesn’t work out? Be honest with yourselves and each other about how you’d handle a breakup within the group.

3. Gauge the Group Dynamics – Are your friends the ride-or-die types who can handle a shift in dynamics, or are they prone to drama? Knowing this in advance can help you decide if it’s worth the risk.

4. Check Your Intentions – Are you genuinely in love, or are you afraid of being alone? Be brutally honest with yourself before jumping in.

5. Prioritize Communication – It’s easy to fall into old friend habits instead of nurturing the relationship. Make a conscious effort to communicate your feelings, expectations, and needs as a couple.

Freedom After the Fall

When the dust settled after my breakup, yes, the group fell apart. But in a strange way, so did the walls that had kept me stuck. I’d clung to that group for security, but it turned out that their disintegration was the catalyst I needed to rediscover myself. Breaking up wasn’t easy, but it forced me to ask hard questions: What do I want from a relationship? What do I need in my friendships? And, most importantly, who am I outside of these group dynamics? It was liberating to finally put myself first. So, should you date someone from your friend group? Maybe. Just know that it’s not all shared playlists and cute inside jokes. Sometimes, the risk outweighs the reward. And if it doesn’t work out, you might lose more than just a relationship—you could lose the group that felt like home.

Then again, maybe that’s not always a bad thing. Sometimes, losing what you thought you needed is the only way to find what you truly deserve. And who knows? Once you step out of that friend group bubble, you might discover a world of new possibilities—and maybe even someone who doesn’t already know your embarrassing karaoke song of choice.

Want to speak about something precisely?

Just tell me, I'll (or we ?) write about it...

You might want to read...